Mind the Information Gap
Derek Malone sat outside Cook County’s Fantus Clinic
in the brilliant fall sunshine, looking tired and discouraged. His stomach hurt and he felt dizzy. It’d been weeks since the 55-year-old had taken medications for his high blood pressure and intestinal ailments – prescriptions he says he can’t afford.
“Ten dollars for a co-pay, I don’t have that,” said Malone, who’s been unemployed and homeless since earlier this year, when his daughter lost a job at a McDonald’s and stopped paying her father to look after her four young children.
“I have zero income, and I get no kind of benefits,” Malone said as resignation crept into his gravelly voice. “The future, man it’s bleak for poor folks like me. I ain’t got no cell phone, no medical card, nothing. You can’t sleep in the streets, the police run you out of the parks. These programs out there, to them I ain’t nothing but a number. It’s a mighty hard pill to swallow.”
|Uninsured until the birth of his child, Henry Edwards negotiated both the symptoms of chronic asthma and the high cost of purchasing medicine to treat it. Parenthood qualified him for Family Care, a public aid program.
Video and gallery by Jay Dunn
Malone has no idea that people in his situation – impoverished adults without dependent children – will be offered assistance starting in 2014 under national health reform, should that legislation survive political and legal challenges.
This lack of awareness isn’t an anomaly: in over a dozen interviews on Chicago’s South and West sides, needy men and women admitted they had never heard of health reform and had no understanding of what it might mean to them.
Told by a reporter that poor adults will benefit from the government’s reform plan, some of these Chicago residents expressed surprise and satisfaction, while others voiced mistrust and skepticism. “It sounds good,” said Theodora Bell, 56, a South Sider with diabetes, high blood pressure and a bad heart who got a Medicaid card a year ago after qualifying for Social Security disability benefits. “Everybody needs insurance because a lot of times, if you don’t have it, doctors don’t even want to see you.”
But after a moment’s reflection, Bell hedged her enthusiasm. “Let’s see what happens with it,” she said, cautiously. “Let’s see if them’s that needs help really gets it.”
Joseph Soria, 64, an immigrant from Ecuador who became a citizen 21 years ago, was confused when a reporter described the legislation’s health insurance provisions. Soria had come for a cholesterol check at a West Town clinic run by CommunityHealth, Chicago’s largest free clinic for the uninsured. “Why do I need insurance when I can come to a place like this?,” he asked, adding “I feel comfortable here; I don’t want to change.”
This gaping chasm between policymakers deciding how to implement health reform, politicians debating the value of this groundbreaking legislation, and residents of some of Chicago’s poorest neighborhoods – many of whom appear to have no idea how reform might impact them – highlights a critical challenge for the groundbreaking initiative that’s come to be known as Obamacare.
“How do we get the word out and educate people? That’s discussed at every meeting I attend,” said Dr. Javette Orgain, chairman of the Illinois State Board of Health and associate clinical professor of family medicine at the University of Illinois at Chicago Medical Center. Her answer: “We’ll have to reach people where they get services and enlist every part of the community – churches, public aid offices, Social Security offices, social service agencies, rehab programs, clinics, all of them have a role to play.”
The basic ingredients of health reform that need to be communicated have far-reaching significance for South Siders and West Siders, as they do for people across Illinois:
For the first time, all adults who earn up to 133 percent of the federal poverty level will qualify for Medicaid, the government’s health program for the poor. (In 2011, that threshold represented a yearly income of over $14,400 for a single person and over $29,700 for a family of four.) In Illinois, adults without dependent children haven’t previously qualified for Medicaid even if they were destitute.
State officials estimate that 500,000 to 800,000 people will be added to the Medicaid rolls in Illinois in 2014, when this provision goes into effect. Most will be single adults or married couples without children.
The Medicaid expansion is certain to affect tens of thousands of people on the South and West sides, where poverty and a lack of health insurance are widespread.
Who will care for new Medicaid members is an open question. Because of budgetary pressures, community-based clinics haven’t yet received funds for a major expansion, as originally contemplated under health reform.
“I think there is the potential for a perfect storm” over access to care if health centers aren’t able to expand to meet impending needs, said Dr. Lee Francis, president of Erie Family Health Center, which serves over 34,000 needy patients a year at 11 sites in Chicago.
Dr. Arthur Jones, a health care consultant and chief medical officer for Medical Home Network, a new healthcare initiative on the Southwest side, said he worried that “there really may not be enough primary and specialty care physicians to deal with this population.”
Indeed, a June 2011 study in the New England Journal of Medicine found that specialty clinics across Cook County denied medical appointments to 66 percent of people posing as Medicaid members seeking care for sick children. If financial pressures on Medicaid escalate as health reform proceeds – a likely scenario – difficulties with accessing care might become even more acute.
Also for the first time, the government will require that every citizen purchase health insurance or obtain it from another source, such as an employer. Recognizing that lower income families won’t be able to afford policies on their own, subsidies will be available starting in 2014 to people with annual incomes between 133 percent and 400 percent of the federal poverty level. (In 2011, that upper threshold represented a yearly income of $43,560 per year for one person and $89,400 for a family of four.)
The government will seek to enforce this insurance mandate by fining people who elect not to purchase coverage. People will pay the higher of two penalties: flat fees beginning at $95 per person in 2014 and climbing to $695 in 2016, or fines consisting of 1 percent of taxable income in 2014 and 2.5 percent in 2016.
People who previously were uninsured and who don’t qualify for Medicaid will have the opportunity to purchase coverage on insurance “exchanges,” including one currently being planned in Illinois. Think of a health insurance mall, with standardized policies offered by different companies and a requirement that coverage be offered to everyone, regardless of pre-existing medical conditions. Up to 300,000 Illinoisans are expected to purchase coverage through the state’s exchange, according to a report from the Illinois Health Care Reform Implementation Council.
“They want to make us buy insurance? I feel it’s too much. We won’t be able to afford it. It’s too high,” said Marian Caruthers, 53, of Calumet City, who drives a van for a private company that doesn’t offer medical coverage. A diabetic, Caruthers had arranged recently to go to CommunityHealth’s clinic in Englewood so a doctor could check on a nasty, persistent cough. Before learning about CommunityHealth a year ago, Caruthers said she’d gone “a long time without seeing a physician, probably about five years.”
“With all the people who are out of work, why would they ask us to spend money on something like this?” Caruthers wondered.
There’s a good answer to that question: with health insurance, low income workers in fast food restaurants, nursing homes, factories and have a better chance of staying healthy and perhaps achieving their aspiration of entering the middle class, said John Bouman, president of the Sargent Shriver National Center on Poverty Law in Chicago. “Without insurance people are more easily distracted by illness and medical bills and they have a more fragile base for staying in the workforce,” he said.
Connecting people with “medical homes” in their communities is another key objective of health reform, despite concerns about medical manpower. Currently, many people in disadvantaged communities don’t have ongoing relationships with primary care doctors and use emergency rooms for basic care – an expensive, inefficient way of receiving medical services.
The health care overhaul addresses the problem by providing more money for primary care and by encouraging medical providers to join together in “accountable care organizations” that assume responsibility for providing cost-effective, high quality medical services.
Illinois’ Medicaid program is moving in the same direction: under legislation passed in January, it’s committed to shifting half of the state’s 2.8 million Medicaid members to managed care or “integrated care” plans that will focus on establishing medical homes for these needy men, women and children.
On the South and West sides, several notable experiments aimed at restructuring medical services are underway. With Medical Home Network, hospitals and clinics have agreed to work more closely together to bolster basic care for Medicaid members and pay closer attention to patients who return home after a hospital stay. The South Side Healthcare Collaborative – a network of more than 30 health clinics and five hospitals – is similarly devoted to establishing “medical homes” for residents.
“For the first time, we are thinking in a systemic way about how we can improve healthcare quality and access,” said Dr. Eric Whitaker, executive vice president of strategic affiliations at the University of Chicago Medical Center, a founding member of the South Side initiative.
To be successful, efforts like these will have to deliver services “in an environment that is culturally and linguistically sensitive” to Latinos, African Americans and various ethnic groups that live on the South and West sides, said Judith Haasis, CommunityHealth’s executive director.
From a patient’s perspective, the new initiatives may mean interacting with new types of medical personnel such as care coordinators, patient navigators and health educators and being encouraged to seek care more regularly, to keep medical problems from worsening or developing in the first place.
That makes sense to Philip Thompson of the South Side, who’s uninsured and unemployed. Thompson had travelled to the Fantus Clinic on a recent afternoon complaining of back pain and seeking narcotics. “You cut back on your health in the name of saving a buck and it’ll cost you two bucks on the other end,” said this lanky, 64-year-old, who acknowledged that he doesn’t “have a clue” about health reform.
Undocumented immigrants will not be eligible for Medicaid under health reform. That will leave a sizeable number of people in the state – between 300,000 and 600,000, according to a report from the Illinois Health Care Reform Implementation Council – still without any type of medical coverage.
The Cook County Health System and other safety net medical providers will struggle to redefine themselves as the ranks of the uninsured diminish and those who remain without coverage are in the country illegally.
In this group will be Talina Morales, 30, whose family crossed the border illegally from Mexico years ago and ended up living in Chicago. A year and a half ago, Morales’ father had his left leg amputated because of poorly managed diabetes; her mother, who’s obese and who works in a flea market on weekends, can barely get around. Morales started going to CommunityHealth for counseling after her brother was murdered earlier this year.
“It’s all a pile of lies; I don’t really care about politics,” said Morales, when told about the health care overhaul. She expects her family to continue going without needed medical care most of the time, despite services available at CommunityHealth and the Cook County Health System.
On the South Side, the future of Cook County’s Provident Hospital has been up in the air for years. Whitaker of the University of Chicago said he worried about that institution closing, saying that “it is a huge resource and health care reform could be a powerful impetus to breathe new life in it.” Discussions between the County and the University of Chicago over Provident’s future have faltered but have started again, with the arrival of a new chief executive at the county health system. “It seems there may be some interest in moving forward,” Whitaker said.
Story by Judith Graham, email@example.com
A sampling of other health reform provisions that will affect consumers:
- Young adults can stay on their parents insurance plans up to the age of 26.
- Insurers can’t sell new policies excluding children with pre-existing conditions.
- Insurance coverage will be guaranteed to anyone with a pre-existing condition in 2014.
- Seniors will have access to a much broader range of preventive services at no extra cost.
- Fewer seniors will fall into the “donut hole” – a coverage gap – when paying for prescription drugs. The donut hole is being phased out by 2020 and seniors’ share of drug costs will diminish.
Judith Graham has covered health policy for dozens of years. For many years, she was a health and medicine correspondent at the Chicago Tribune. Her work has appeared in the Washington Post, Los Angeles Times, Baltimore Sun, Philadelphia Inquirer, Seattle Times and the New York Times, among other publications.
See our Neighborhood Stories videos in HD on IHM’s Vimeo channel.
Illinois Health Matters presented accessible, personal stories about how health care reform is impacting underserved communities on the South and West sides of Chicago. These stories were part of the Local Reporting Initiative, supported in part by The Chicago Community Trust.